Cutting tool executive cautions manufacturers about ‘Made in USA’ label

Cutting tool executive cautions manufacturers about ‘Made in USA’ label

U.S. toolmakers should "claim the origin of [their] products," he said during a speech at an industry event hosted by the grinding-machine and EDM builder Vollmer. Viaud-Murat pointed out, though, that manufacturers should not claim a product is U.S.-made if it isn't. Doing so could result in legal action against the offending company, initiated by the Federal Trade Commission.

March 21, 2017By Don Nelson

Eighty percent of Americans prefer to buy American-made goods than imported ones. Moreover, 60 percent of Americans are willing to pay 10 percent more for a U.S.-manufactured product than the same type of product made overseas, said Pierre Viaud-Murat, vice president of sales at cutting tool manufacturer Ceratizit USA Inc.

U.S. toolmakers should "claim the origin of [their] products," he said during a speech at an industry event hosted by the grinding-machine and EDM builder Vollmer. Viaud-Murat pointed out, though, that manufacturers should not claim a product is U.S.-made if it isn't. Doing so could result in legal action against the offending company, initiated by the Federal Trade Commission.

According to FTC rules, claiming a product is U.S.-made requires that "all or virtually all" of the product be produced in the U.S. The FTC states: " 'All or virtually all' means that all significant parts and processing that go into the product must be of U.S. origin. That is, the product should contain no — or negligible — foreign content."

Viaud-Murat cited examples of products that did and didn't meet the commission's U.S.-origin requirements:

  • A gas grill fabricated in America that incorporates knobs, tubes, pipes and assorted fittings manufactured in Mexico met the FTC standard. The Mexican components weren't considered integral to the grill's operation.
  • A lamp consisting of an imported wood base and a U.S.-made metal stand and glass shade did not meet the standard. The commission deemed the imported base a "significant" component of the lamp.
  • A wrench made from a Chinese forging was ruled as not made in the U.S., despite the fact 85 percent of the tool's value came from grinding processes performed in America.

U.S. companies should use a qualified origination term when foreign content in their products exceeds FTC rules. Examples include:

  • "Made in U.S.A. of U.S. and Imported Parts."
  • "Designed in U.S.A., Made in China."
  • "Ground and Coated in U.S.A."
  • "60% U.S. Content."

Besides cutting tools, Ceratizit USA, Warren, Mich., produces carbide powders and carbide blanks in Pennsylvania. "Using U.S.-made carbide blanks is a marketing opportunity" for American toolmakers, said Viaud-Murat, noting that Ceratizit USA's powders and blanks cost approximately 3 percent more than those produced at the parent company's plants in China.

Sales of the company's American-made blanks and powders are "doing well," Viaud-Murat said, and output can be increased if demand rises.

[Note: Cutting Tool Engineering magazine is written, edited, produced and printed in the U.S. on U.S.-made paper.—Ed.]