Ask the Grinding Doc: The question is academic
Invited to join a 3-year academic project, a grinding wheel manufacturer turned to the Grinding Doc to determine whether such projects are worth the money and, more importantly, the time. For its part, the company is interested in evaluating its bond formulations.
Dear Doc: I work for a grinding wheel manufacturer that’s been invited to join a 3-year academic project. The financial investment isn’t big, but I’m wondering if the project is worth the money and, especially, our time. We’re interested in evaluating our bond formulations.
The Doc Replies: For companies in industry, academic projects can be a big win—or a complete waste of time—depending on the project and how it’s run. First, let’s look at the what’s-in-it-for-me aspect for each participant.
Professors need funding for their doctoral students, as well as articles to be published in academic journals—the publish-or-perish phenomenon. Doctoral students need to find some novel, original, scientific aspect of the research, hopefully with the help of the professor. They also must get journal articles published based on their work. Industrial partners typically want to learn something practical to help their businesses, such as the behavior of a new bond formulation in a specific grinding application.
Let’s imagine an ideal situation: While performing tests on wheels with various bond formulations, the student measures grinding forces, workpiece surface finish and wheel wear, and analyzes the worn wheel with an electron microscope. The student then reports the results to the industrial partner. The group members share knowledge so they can evaluate how the different bonds and, perhaps, the bond constitution affect grinding.
Review the print ads from this magazine to continue
This quick advertiser review unlocks the rest of the article and keeps the full-screen reader focused on the ads instead of the page chrome.
Advertisers included in this article experience
Print placements connected to this article
Toolflo
Your Threading Specialist!
CHASERS API Threading chasers! • Buttress, WW, NPT, Rounds... Superior coatings! Combination Bar FLO-LOCK Turning ,Threading and Facing ON-EDGE All-in-one! LAYDOWN Thousands of new items added to our new Threading Catalog! State of the art coatings! Pressed, ground and raised chip breakers! THREADMILLING Indexible and solid threadmills!
Your Threading Specialist! CHASERS API Threading chasers! • Buttress, WW, NPT, Rounds... Superior coatings! Combination Bar FLO-LOCK Turning ,Threading and Facing ON-EDGE All-in-one! LAYDOWN
Visit Toolflo View this placement in the issue recordYg1usa
BEST VALUE IN THE WORLD OF CUTTING TOOLS!
COATED SOLID CARBIDE END MILLS Coated Ultra Micro Grain Solid Carbide End Mills with Variable Helix High Volume Cutting with Quality Surface Finish For Steels (up to HRc40), and also Excellent in Stainless Steels YG-1 TOOL CO. 730 Corporate Woods Parkway Vernon Hills, IL 60061 U.S.A.
BEST VALUE IN THE WORLD OF CUTTING TOOLS! www.yg1usa.com COATED SOLID CARBIDE END MILLS Coated Ultra Micro Grain Solid Carbide End Mills with Variable Helix High Volume Cutting with Quality Surface Finish For Steels (up to HRc40), and also Excellent in Stainless Steels YG-1 TOOL CO. 730 Corporate Woods Parkway Vernon Hills, IL 60061 U.S.A PHONE: 800-765-8665, Technical Assistance: 888-868-5988
Visit Yg1usa View this placement in the issue recordPrint ads from this magazine
CHASERS API Threading chasers! • Buttress, WW, NPT, Rounds... Superior coatings! Combination Bar FLO-LOCK Turning ,Threading and Facing ON-EDGE All-in-one! LAYDOWN Thousands of new items added to our new Threading Catalog! State of the art coatings! Pressed, ground and raised chip breakers! THREADMILLING Indexible and solid threadmills!
Your Threading Specialist! CHASERS API Threading chasers! • Buttress, WW, NPT, Rounds... Superior coatings! Combination Bar FLO-LOCK Turning ,Threading and Facing ON-EDGE All-in-one! LAYDOWN
Continue reading
June 2017
There may be another round of tests after some bond modifications. The student and professor then develop something novel for the thesis and academic articles. For example, how the bond bridges are fracturing or the impact of a bond additive on wheel wear. Meanwhile, with their new understanding of these bonds, the company develops new, better wheels. It’s a win-win-win.
But the process doesn’t always go smoothly. What are some potential pitfalls? The industrial partner may have unrealistic expectations, thinking the partnership will generate some revolutionary insight that will double sales. The professor may not know enough about grinding to design a test program that yields meaningful results. The test design is as important as the test. Perhaps the professor wants to develop some fancy, half-finished, complex abrasion model and plans to use much of the student’s time for that purpose—which doesn’t directly benefit the company.
Ask the professor to explain the game plan. If it’s too complicated to explain in layman’s terms, it probably won’t benefit you. Finally, beware of intellectual property issues. The professor wants to publish any findings, but may be restricted if what you develop is proprietary.
I’ve seen academic projects yield positive results for everybody. I’ve also seen academic projects yield frustration all around. Make sure you’re getting into something practical and be realistic in your expectations.
Glossary terms in this article
Related
MFGAxis Discussion
Be part of the shop-floor conversation
Like, save, or comment on this CTE story.
MFGAxis Discussion